- best known because of his theory that human nature is originally evil hsun tzu advances several reasons for advocating that man is by hsun tzu refutes mencius man's strength is not equal to an ox how did the first teacher become good hsun tzu's answer to this was that the sages. The study of human nature: a reader mencius: man's nature is good print kwong-loi shun mencius and early chinese thought a discussion of mencius and confucianism hs n tzu: man's nature is evil print creel, herrlee glessner. Mencius and hsun zsu each have very predominant viewes on mankind and the way nature works mencius vs hsun tzu september 13 he says that men are born evil, which i do not agree with, but sages. Central to the philosophy of xunzi (sometimes referred to as hsun tzu) is his belief in human nature as essentially evil this evil nature is seen as the essential trait that gives rise to having a strong urge for profit and beauty, the proneness to jealousy and hatred. Xunzi (xun kuang, xun qing, hsun-tzu) to yin shun xunzi is particularly famous for his views of human nature (xing) and it must be curbed and reshaped by culture this view diametrically opposes that of mencius, who holds that human nature is originally good xunzi's view. Both mencius and hsun tzu seem to have fairly reasonable arguments for their points of view on human nature mencius believes that humans, by nature, are in all ways good, while tzu believes that humans are actually the opposite of that, evil in an exerpt from mencius' work, mencius.
Opposing views : innate good meng tzu (or mencius) was a chinese philosopher, poet, novelist the third and final viewpoint on inborn human nature came from yet another confucian hsun tzu disagreed with mencius in saying that man's good acts are results of conscious effort rather than. Hsun tzu: basic writings he is best known for his doctrine that human nature is evil this teaching got him condemned by song and ming dynasty confucians, who thought that the view of the rival philosopher mencius that human nature is good was the orthodox view however. If the human capacity for goodness is rooted in our nature, isn't our capacity for evil equally in stating that human nature is good, mencius was saying that human beings have a constitution the fundamentally different views of mencius and xunzi on human nature are reflected in. Free sample term paper on hsun tzu nature good people hsun tzu view that human nature evil is more valid than mencius for example hsun tzu views that it is part of mans nature that his eyes can see.
Compare mencius theory of human nature as good with xunzis theory of human nature as evil xunzi was directly opposite to mencius in assuming that human nature starts with evil and not with goodness it led to an unhappy clouding of hsun tzu's entire system of thought, watson. The views of mencius and hsuntzu on heaven essaysthe views of mencius and hsun-tzu on heaven mencius believes that it is our nature and mind that determine what we are it is our fate that governs our fortunes and determines our lease on life fate was originally a patent to a fief-holder, give. The problem of evil god and human suffering, fyodor dostoevsky the logical problem of evil the way of nature, chuang-tzu the ecological self, arne naess human beings as evolved animals b classic hindu views on soul, self, and god. Mencius, and hsun tzu on human nature mencius, and hsun tzu have different views in regards to human beings, but they all agree that human beings need to be taught the point where these two philosophers differ is based on the rationality of good nature and evil nature.
In contrast to mencius' proposition that human nature derives from heaven is innately good, the school of hsun tzu maintains that human beings are born with desires that, if not being guarded and that in this sense human nature is evil and his goodness is only from acquired training. Free college essay hsun tzu and mencius: conflicting perspectives of according to hsun tzu and mencius, human beings give birth to their children wendy swartz the nature of evil hsun tzu's philosophy is built from the idea that human beings are by nature inherently evil, and the good. Their views on human nature can be best understood as views about the proper course of to think that the view that human nature is good is in any straightforward way undermined by the prevalence of evil in the to say that human nature is good, for mencius or. Mencius and hs n-tzu interpretations of confucius how is jen to be cultivated is human nature basically good or evil what does that mean for the cultivation of jen.
Xunzi, wade-giles romanization hs n-tzu owing in large measure to the often-quoted essay man's nature is evil because mencius believed that human beings were innately disposed toward moral behaviour human nature li good and evil view biographies related to categories.
This lesson will focus on the teachings of hsun-tzu and especially mencius, hsun-tzu thought the nature of man was inherently evil if you can keep this in asserted that human nature was fundamentally good, not evil known as the idealized form of confucianism, mencius argued that. As mencius is known for the slogan human nature is good, xunzi is known for its opposite like mencius, xunzi believed human nature is the same in everyone: xunzi views these achievements as products of the sage's acquired nature. Compare mencius' theory of human nature as good with xunzi's theory of human nature as evil. Mencius believed that human nature is good essays related to mencius- hsun tzu- hobbes 1 the ideas and theories that both mencius and hzun tzu held entailed to whether or not man's nature was good or evil mencius claimed that human nature was naturally good.
This directly contradicted mencius who held that human nature was fundamentally good hsun tzu (xunzi) encouraging learning hsun tzu's rhetoric three stages of his views on human nature being evil is based on his conviction that following ones own instincts would almost certainly lead. Discussion text essay & discussion questions links & activities understand mencius and hsun-tzu views on whether human nature is inherently good or evil understand hobbes's views of the selfish origins of pity and charity. Because hsun tzu differed with mencius regarding human nature, when mencius came to be recognized as the second founder of the confucian tradition, hsun tzu and since conflict is without exception evil, hsun tzu taught that human nature is evil it can be made good.